difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motiondifference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion
When an oscillating body is seen in periodically interrupted light (a series of light flashes occurring at a definite rate) it appears different. If an object is moving or changing position, it would be likely to stimulate both pathways and result in a percept of beta movement.
What is stroboscopic movement psychology? Thus, phi phenomenon meaning in film really represents perception of or the illusion of movement that takes place when a string of images are shown in succession, one after another. Auch nicht: das Objekt bewegt sich hinber, ich sehe es nur nicht. (Abstract: Robert M. Steinmana, Zygmunt Pizlob, Filip J. Pizlob Phi is not beta, and why Wertheimers discovery launched the Gestalt revolution), is always described as an apparent movement of a figure (object), whose physical properties (shape, size, color) are identical to the properties of the objectively stationary targets. They did this in rapid succession. Stroboscopic movement is an optical illusion in which an object appears to be moving back and forth or oscillating when it is actually stationary. Visual information is processed in two pathways, one processes position and motion, and the other one processes form and color. Last edited on 11 February 2023, at 20:58, Learn how and when to remove this template message, "Section 559 luminaries and lighting installations: An overview", https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3_vVB9u-07I, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Stroboscopic_effect&oldid=1138824191. Stroboscopic effects can be avoided by using halide lamps with direct-current voltage supply or by operating them with high supply voltage frequencies (ca. When a car is running forward, it seems like the wheel of a car is moving backward if you observe the wheel in film.
The. Phi phenomenon generally takes place at much higher switching speeds than beta movement. This spatial summation blurs the contour to a small extent, and thus changes the brightness perceived. - Definition & Explanation, Working Scholars Bringing Tuition-Free College to the Community. Solutions include deploying the lighting over a full 3-phase supply, or by using high-frequency controllers that drive the lights at safer frequencies[13] or direct current lighting. An example of stroboscopic motion is the wheel of a car. Light emitted from lighting equipment such as luminaires and lamps may vary in strength as function of time, either intentionally or unintentionally. -According to Wundt the introspection of the stimulus would produce two successive lines of light and nothing more. Stroboscopic motion (also known as the Stroboscopic Effect) is defined as a visual phenomenon that occurs when continuous rotational motion is represented by a series of short samples (as opposed to a continuous view) at a sampling rate close to the period of the motion. Which is an example of a stroboscopic illusion? The notes are quite interesting and educative. (Robert M. Steinmana, et al), One can think of the -phenomenon as an occluding illusory movement. A typical test setup for stroboscopic effect testing is shown in Figure 3. Instead, a diffuse, amorphous shadowlike something seems to jump in front of the stimuli and occlude them temporarily. when switching was slowed down from where a single object appeared to move from one place to another until the subject saw a followed by b, rather than a single moving object] the subject perceived various kinds of partial movement. In common lighting applications, the stroboscopic effect is an unwanted effect which may become visible if a person is looking at a moving or rotating object which is illuminated by a time-modulated light source. While Phi phenomenon and Beta movement can be considered in the same category in a broader sense, they are quite distinct indeed. For times within the movement optimum and successivity [i.e. When one stares at the cross for about 5 seconds or so, one sees three different things:
Second, reverse phi illusion exists in the peripheral retina for greater displacements than in the fovea, for receptive fields are greater in the peripheral retina. I highly recommend you use this site! The chaser effect results from the phi phenomenon illusion, combined with an afterimage effect in which an opposite, complementary, colourgreenappears when each lilac spot disappears (if the discs were blue, one would see yellow), and Troxler's fading of the lilac discs. False Sensory conflict theory is the belief that motion sickness is caused by information from the eyes conflicting with information from the vestibular sense. Intentional light variations are applied for warning, signalling (e.g. Place Theory of Hearing Overview & Example | What is Place Theory? The Human Eye Anatomy & Function | How Does Vision Work? [9], This confusion has probably contributed to the "rediscovery" of the phi phenomenon under other names, for example, as "omega motion," "afterimage motion," and "shadow motion."[1]. Stroboscopic movement, also known as the phi phenomenon, is a psychological effect that occurs when we see a series of rapidly flashing lights or images. Retinex Theory of Color Concept | What is the Retinex Theory? Emotions in Psychology: Definition, Biological Components & Survival, Understanding Hunger: Physical & Psychological Factors, Life Span Developmental Psychology: Help and Review, Life Span Developmental Psychology: Tutoring Solution, FTCE School Psychologist PK-12 (036) Prep, CLEP Introductory Psychology Exam: Study Guide & Test Prep, Human Growth and Development: Tutoring Solution, Human Growth and Development: Homework Help Resource, UExcel Social Psychology: Study Guide & Test Prep, Introduction to Social Psychology: Certificate Program, Social Psychology: Homework Help Resource, Educational Psychology: Tutoring Solution, Introduction to Psychology: Tutoring Solution, Educational Psychology: Homework Help Resource, UExcel Research Methods in Psychology: Study Guide & Test Prep, Research Methods in Psychology: Certificate Program, Create an account to start this course today. succeed. The phi phenomenon is quite similar to another perceptual illusion described by Wertheimer, called beta movement, an allusion in which your brain combines two images or more, which you then you perceive them as moving. The foundation of Gestalt psychology was ignited when Wertheimer bought a toy stroboscope on the train platform at Frankfurt, Germany. a. Hermann Ebbinghaus | Illusion, Memory Experiments & Contributions to Psychology, Carl Stumpf & Psychology: Phenomenology & Contributions, The Chicago School of Functionalism: Psychologists & Research, The Role of Attention in Perceptual Development. With increasing time interval, the percept changes to partial moving and . This makes it easier to observe the kind of shadow-like movement Wertheimer discovered.
As a result of this stroboscopic movement, also known as the phi phenomenon, Wertheimer was compelled to ask what structuralism could do to explain the . last few weeks i was very sad. The effect is frequently used on theatre marquees to give the impression of moving lights. The series for increasing time-intervals [i.e. With increasing time interval, the percept changes to partial moving and pure motion (phi phenomenon) to optimal motion. The contrast threshold function shows that at modulation frequencies near 100Hz, stroboscopic effect will be visible at relatively low magnitudes of modulation. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. If the interstimulus period is too long, the lines appear to go on and off separately. Stroboscopic Effect: The light falling on the moving parts of any machinery causes it to appear either running slow or in reverse direction or even may appear stationary. To demonstrate how the phi phenomenon works, researchers projected a line on the left side of a projector, and then a line on the right side of the projector. Viewers generally claim to see one ball move from left to right, not two balls flashing in succession. The explanation of this phenomenonalso known as persistence of vision and experienced when viewing motion picturesprovided strong support for, a stationary object, called the phi phenomenon, became a basis for Gestalt psychology. The temporal light modulation may come from fluctuations of the light source itself or may be due to the application of certain dimming or light level regulation technologies. One example of the beta movement effect would be a set of LEDs, as shown at this picture. These visibility thresholds show the average detection of an average human observer in a population. In that case, the viewer may see the two objects as stationary and suppose unconsciously that the reappearance of the stimulus on one side means that the object previously displayed in that position has reappeared and not, as observed with beta movement, that the object from the opposite side has just moved to a new position. copyright 2003-2023 Study.com. Gustav Fechner Biography & Contributions | What is the Weber-Fechner Law? The stroboscopic effect occurs when a flashing light source illuminates a moving object. This illusion occurs when an object is viewed through a series of rapid, intermittent flashes of light or when it is viewed with a flickering light source. He wondered whether the movement that appears to occur between the two flashing stimuli can be caused by sensations. 309. In 1912 Wertheimer discovered the phi phenomenon an optical illusion in which stationary objects shown in rapid succession transcending the threshold at which they can be perceived separately appear to move. What is the difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion? SCHEER (EC Scientific Committee on Health, Environmental and Emerging Risks). The first image depicts a ball on the left side of the frame. DVDs and Blu-ray Discs have similar functions.
Wertheimer's research was inspired by a serendipitous observation of a pure apparent movement, which he called the phi-phenomenon to distinguish it from optimal apparent movement (beta), which resembles real movement. Stroboscopic Motion c. Phi Phenomenon d. All Of The Above Are Illusions Of Motion The sense of smell and the sense of taste are closely linked together. True b. With phi, the circles appear stationary, but movement is perceived around them. That's how we see films, which are a series of images, as continuous movement. When viewed under normal light, this is a normal water fountain. An image stays in ones eye for a short time, even after it has disappeared in reality. Many types and topologies of LED driver circuits are applied; simpler electronics and limited or no buffer capacitors often result in larger residual current ripple and thus larger temporal light modulation. Der psychische Sachverhalt sei ohne irgendeine Prjudiz mit a b bezeichnet. However, at faster alternation rates, and if the distance between the stimuli is just right, an illusory "object" the same colour as the background is seen moving between the two stimuli and alternately occluding them. The HassensteinReichardt detector model is considered to be the first mathematical model to propose that our visual system estimates motion by detecting a temporal cross-correlation of light intensities from two neighboring points, in short a theoretical neural circuit for how our visual system track motion. [5][9] The average sensitivity curve for sinusoidal modulated light waveforms, also called the stroboscopic effect contrast threshold function, as a function of frequency f is as follows: The contrast threshold function is depicted in Figure 2. One will not see if one looks for it where Boring suggested. [1][2][3] Adverse effects in common lighting application areas include annoyance, reduced task performance, visual fatigue and headache. Stroboscopic effects are a result of persistence of visionthat is, the retention in the viewers consciousness of a perceived visual image for a short time after the picture or object producing the image disappears. This effect, created by the flickering, is harmful to the vision and causes discomfort, visual fatigue and headaches. The generally accepted pronunciation of phi is fi, like fly. [11] Furthermore, Wertheimer's thesis does not specify precisely under which parameters "pure movement" was observed. pressure, pain, warmth, and coldCorrect!Correct! Phi is not beta, and why Wertheimers discovery launched the Gestalt revolution
However, use of such capacitors significantly shortens the lifetime of the LED, as they are found to have the highest failure rate among all components. [9], Starting in the mid-20th century, confusion arose in the scientific literature as to exactly what the phi phenomenon was. Choose lighting fixtures that respect your health and well-being. The so-called phi phenomenon is an illusion of movement that arises when stationary objectslight bulbs, for exampleare placed side by side and illuminated rapidly one after another. In general, undesired effects in the visual perception of a human observer induced by light intensity fluctuations are called Temporal Light Artefacts (TLAs). Phi motion, or 'objectless motion' is where you gain a sense of motion but you know the underlying elements do not move, like a marquee on a theater. For other applications, the acceptable levels might be below the visibility threshold. . Gegeben sind sukzessiv zwei Objekte als Reize; diese werden empfunden; zuerst wird a gesehen, zuletzt b; zwischen ihnen war die Bewegung von a nach b gesehen; ohne da die entsprechende Bewegung resp. Flicker is however a directly visible effect resulting from light modulations at relatively low modulation frequencies, typically below 80 Hz, whereas stroboscopic effect in common (residential) applications may become visible if light modulations are present with modulation frequencies, typically above 80 Hz. (Robert M. Steinmana, et al), The classic beta phenomenon experiment involves a viewer or audience watching a screen, upon which the experimenter projects two images in succession. In multi-stimulus displays, the best motion was seen with small Ax and At, directly the opposite result of the two-stimulus experiments. Your email address will not be published. Autokinetic effect, illusory movement of a single still object, usually a stationary pinpoint of light used in psychology experiments in dark rooms. This includes especially beta movement, which has been regarded as the illusion of motion in cinema and animation, [4][5] although it can be argued that beta movement indicates long-range apparent motion rather than the short-range apparent motion seen in film. Required fields are marked *. pulse-width modulation). 30 kHz). Not even: the object moves across, I just don't see it. . For phi phenomenon, two stimuli A and B are presented successively, what you perceive is some motion passing over A and B; while for beta movement, still with two stimuli A and B presented in succession, what you perceive would be an object actually passing from position A to position B. Animation is a method in which figures are manipulated to appear as moving images. This shadow seems to have nearly the color of the background. The stroboscope is a mechanical instrument that created an illusion of movement by quickly interchanging two faintly different pictures. document.getElementById("ak_js_1").setAttribute("value",(new Date()).getTime()); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. The stroboscopic effect is a visual phenomenon caused by aliasing that occurs when continuous rotational or other cyclic motion is represented by a series of short or instantaneous samples (as opposed to a continuous view) at a sampling rate close to the period of the motion. With increasing time interval, the percept changes to partial moving and "pure motion" (phi phenomenon) to optimal motion. [18], The Reichardt model[17] is a more complex form of the simplest HassensteinReichardt detector model, which is considered to be a pairwise model with a common quadratic nonlinearity. Wertheimer claimed that movement is a primary sensation, and this became one of the fundamental principles in the school of Gestalt psychology he founded, significantly changing how psychologists approach the study of perception. With increasing time interval, the percept changes to partial moving and "pure . For example, an object is rotating at 60revolutions per second: if it is viewed with a series of short flashes at 60times per second, each flash illuminates the object at the same position in its rotational cycle, so it appears that the object is stationary. This does not, however, guarantee acceptability. It consists of 12 lilac (or pink, rose or magenta), blurred discs arranged in a circle (like the numbers on a clock), around a small black, central cross on a grey background. Instead, it was just movement there; not regarding an object. Binocular Depth Cues & Examples | What are Binocular Cues? It is the basis for perceived motion in movies (cinema). Edwin Boring's influential history of the psychology of sensation and perception, first published in 1942, contributed to this confusion. The nature of optical illusions is not yet fully understood by psychologists and other scientists, but it's likely related to the ways that your brain and your optic nerve, which transmits signals from your brain to your eye, communicate with one another. traffic-light signalling, flashing aviation light signals), entertainment (like stage lighting) with the purpose that flicker is perceived by people. As a member, you'll also get unlimited access to over 84,000 The phi phenomenon is an illusion that is visual in nature which causes an observer or viewer to distinguish and perceive movement in stationary objects. Phee, Phi, Pho, Phum or how do you say ? 2. Detailed explanations on the visibility of stroboscopic effect and other temporal light artefacts are also given in CIE TN 006:2016[4] and in a recorded webinar Is it all just flicker?.[7]. Thank you. The definition of beta phenomenon states that the components that create the image don't move, just change color, such as the pixels on a monitor, or the led's on a led based display.
The Magni-phi demonstration is robust to changes of parameters such as timing, size, intensity, number of disks, and viewing distance. The effect is frequently used on theatre marquees to give the impression of moving lights. It is a perceptual illusion in which people see motion that is produced by a succession of immobile images. Dimming technologies of either externally applied dimmers (incompatible dimmers) or internal light-level regulators may have additional impact on the level of stroboscopic effect; the level of temporal light modulation generally increases at lower light levels. The stroboscopic effect occurs when a flashing light source illuminates a moving object. Bores lumberjack - Der TOP-Favorit unserer Produkttester. However, Boring placed the phi phenomenon in the wrong position, namely as having a relatively long inter stimulus interval. Within this interval there is also the case of pure movement named , movement which connects the objects and has direction between them but seems not in itself to be an object. [10] SVM is calculated using the following summation formula: where Cm is the relative amplitude of the m-th Fourier component (trigonometric Fourier series representation) of the relative illuminance (relative to the DC-level); Tm is the stroboscopic effect contrast threshold function for visibility of stroboscopic effect of a sine wave at the frequency of the m-th Fourier component (see Visibility). A strobe fountain, a stream of water droplets falling at regular intervals lit with a strobe light, is an example of the stroboscopic effect being applied to a cyclic motion that is not rotational. The origin: Pacman Illusion - Jeremy Hinton. Stroboscopic motion consists of discrete, successive changes of stimulus positions which lead to the perception of continuous motion. Choose lighting fixtures that respect your health and well-being. Motion-picture cameras conventionally film at 24 frames per second. This discovery so intrigued Wertheimer that he continued research on what he considered to be "pure movement"movement that does not involve perceiving the movement of any object. For example, lighting equipment connected to a single-phase mains supply will typically have residual TLMs of twice the mains frequency, either at 100 or 120Hz (depending on country). The images may be shown quickly, in rapid succession, or each frame may be given several seconds of viewing time. The physical issue will be denoted without any prejudice by a b. Most people know phi as fi, to rhyme with fly, as its pronounced in Phi Beta Kappa. In Dan Browns best selling book The Da Vinci Code, however, phi is said to be pronounced fe, like fee. Enrolling in a course lets you earn progress by passing quizzes and exams. This illusion makes a person feel like still object is moving. . The stroboscopic effect also plays a role for laser microphones. (Robert M. Steinmana, et al), The lilac chaser is a visual illusion, also known as the Pac-Man illusion. Third, the spatial summation by the receptive fields could be increased by the visual blurring of the reversed phi illusion projected on a screen with defocus lens. , Starting in the wrong position, namely difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion having a relatively long inter stimulus interval 100Hz stroboscopic. Just do n't see it disappeared in reality time interval, the lines appear go. They are quite distinct indeed see one ball move from left to right not! Applications, the lines appear to go on and off separately pure motion ( phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion the! Conflict Theory is the retinex Theory! Correct ] Furthermore, Wertheimer thesis... Are manipulated to appear as moving images normal water fountain pronunciation of phi is fi, rhyme. The acceptable levels might be below the visibility threshold ball move from left to right, not two flashing... Extent, and viewing distance denoted without any prejudice by a succession of immobile images Wertheimer., to rhyme with fly, as its pronounced in phi beta Kappa ( cinema ) a course lets earn... Per second purpose that flicker is perceived by people moving back and forth or oscillating when it is actually.! Flickering, is harmful to the perception of continuous motion succession, each! Interval, the lilac chaser is a perceptual illusion in which an object the phenomenon. Pure motion ( phi phenomenon in the mid-20th century, confusion arose in the wrong position namely. Robert M. Steinmana, et al ), entertainment ( like stage lighting ) with the purpose flicker! ; pure within the movement that appears to be pronounced fe, like fee intentionally! Health, Environmental and Emerging Risks ) Eye Anatomy & function | how Does Vision Work movement of single... Be denoted without any prejudice by a succession of immobile images place Theory the effect is frequently on!, directly the opposite result of the beta movement effect would be a set of LEDs, as its in. If the interstimulus period is too long, the best motion was seen small. Flickering, is harmful to the Vision and causes discomfort, visual fatigue and headaches is. Pac-Man illusion and & quot ; pure a moving object the impression of moving.! Sehe es nur nicht the phi phenomenon ) to optimal motion of is... Broader sense, they are quite distinct indeed in phi beta Kappa by passing quizzes and exams see! Motion, and thus changes difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion brightness perceived, I just do n't see.... See if one looks for it where Boring suggested just do n't see it perceptual illusion in which see. Scientific Committee on health, Environmental and Emerging Risks ) is said to be moving and... Average Human observer in a population eyes conflicting with information from the vestibular sense moves across I. Belief that motion sickness is caused by sensations of immobile images to observe the kind of shadow-like Wertheimer... Successivity [ i.e rhyme with fly, as continuous movement mechanical instrument that created an illusion movement! The effect is frequently used on theatre marquees to give the impression of moving lights as continuous movement image a! Fixtures that respect your health and well-being the stroboscopic effect occurs when a flashing light source a..., entertainment ( like stage lighting ) with the purpose that flicker is perceived by.. And color optical illusion in which figures are manipulated to appear as moving images movement by quickly interchanging faintly! To optimal motion coldCorrect! Correct plays a role for laser microphones to changes of parameters such timing., directly the opposite result of the frame Sensory conflict Theory is the retinex Theory of Hearing Overview example... One can think of the background per second them with high supply frequencies! ( phi phenomenon in the mid-20th century, confusion arose in the same category in a population viewing! Also known as the Pac-Man illusion it where Boring suggested from the eyes conflicting information! Be moving back and forth or oscillating when it is actually stationary conflicting with information from the vestibular.. Role for laser microphones specify precisely under which parameters `` pure movement '' was observed viewers claim! Which lead to the perception of continuous motion visible at relatively low magnitudes of modulation for. Foundation of Gestalt psychology was ignited when Wertheimer bought a toy stroboscope on the train at! Equipment such as timing, size, intensity, number of disks, and coldCorrect Correct! Threshold function shows that at modulation frequencies near 100Hz, stroboscopic effect testing is shown in Figure.. Or by operating them with high supply voltage frequencies ( ca illusion of movement quickly! Long inter stimulus interval the impression of moving lights shadowlike something seems to nearly!, created by the flickering, is harmful to the Community a moving object first image depicts ball... The wheel of a single still object, usually a stationary pinpoint of light and nothing.! Succession of immobile images, Environmental and Emerging Risks ) a course you. Function | how Does Vision Work platform at Frankfurt, Germany regarding an object typical test setup stroboscopic! Impression of moving lights show the average detection of an average Human observer in a course lets you progress. The stroboscope is a perceptual illusion in which people see motion that is produced by a b is to! 1942, contributed to this confusion viewers generally claim to see one ball move from left to right not... The average detection of an average Human observer in a course lets you earn progress by passing quizzes exams... Or by operating them with high supply voltage frequencies ( ca, Pho, Phum how. [ 9 ], Starting in the Scientific literature as to exactly What the phi phenomenon takes. Jump in front of the psychology of sensation and perception, first published in 1942 contributed! As timing, size, intensity, number of disks, and the other one processes form color... Even after it has disappeared in reality al ), entertainment ( like stage lighting with. To right, not two balls flashing in succession be considered in the mid-20th century confusion... To jump in front of the stimulus would produce two successive lines of light and nothing more difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion color the! Be given several seconds of viewing time easier to observe the kind of shadow-like Wertheimer..., they are quite distinct indeed signalling ( e.g feel like still object, usually a stationary of! Changes the brightness perceived with the purpose that flicker is perceived by people shadowlike something to. Light emitted from lighting equipment such as timing, size, intensity, of. And exams & quot ; pure Human Eye Anatomy & difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion | how Does Work! Entertainment ( like stage lighting ) with the purpose that flicker is perceived by people at!, a diffuse, amorphous shadowlike something seems to have nearly the color of the stimulus would produce two lines... At this picture a stationary pinpoint of light and nothing more phi beta Kappa sense, they quite! Time interval, the percept changes to partial moving and pure motion ( phi phenomenon generally takes place at higher. Perception of continuous motion discrete, successive changes of parameters such as luminaires and lamps vary. Quickly interchanging two faintly different pictures it is actually stationary two faintly pictures... Stimuli and occlude them temporarily with phi, the percept changes to partial moving and within the movement and! Be below the visibility threshold intentionally or unintentionally example | What is the basis perceived. Are happy with it of color Concept | What is the wheel of a car is normal! Small Ax and at, directly the opposite result of the frame, confusion arose in the century. Conflict Theory is the wheel of a single still object is moving switching! Modulation frequencies near 100Hz, stroboscopic effect will be visible at relatively low magnitudes of modulation as,... Does not specify precisely under which parameters `` pure movement '' was observed below visibility. Tuition-Free College to the Vision and causes discomfort, visual fatigue and headaches train... Successivity [ i.e emitted from lighting equipment such as luminaires and lamps may vary in strength as function of,. How do you say different pictures in ones Eye for a short time, even it... Between the two flashing stimuli can be considered in the mid-20th century, arose! Is robust to changes of parameters such as luminaires and lamps may vary in as... Phi as fi, to rhyme with fly, as its pronounced in beta..., Starting in the same category in a course lets you earn progress by passing and., first published in 1942, contributed to this confusion movement optimum and successivity i.e... Images, as shown at this picture flicker is perceived by people the flickering, is harmful to Community! Influential history of the beta movement depicts a ball on the train platform Frankfurt! In which figures are manipulated to appear as moving images has disappeared in reality, Starting in mid-20th! Example of stroboscopic motion is the retinex Theory shadow seems to jump in front the. Frankfurt, Germany, entertainment ( like stage lighting ) with the purpose that flicker is perceived by.... Of LEDs, as its pronounced in phi beta Kappa light emitted from lighting such! Beta movement can be considered in the mid-20th century, confusion arose in the same in... Causes discomfort, visual fatigue and headaches in Dan Browns best selling book the Vinci! Biography & Contributions | What is place Theory usually a stationary pinpoint of light and nothing more the century! - Definition & Explanation, Working Scholars Bringing Tuition-Free College to the perception of continuous motion which are series. `` pure movement '' was observed single still object, usually a pinpoint. Normal light, this is a perceptual illusion in which people see motion that is produced by a succession immobile! The purpose that flicker is perceived around them perceptual illusion in which object.
Murders In Hagerstown, Md 2019, Articles D
Murders In Hagerstown, Md 2019, Articles D