He'd fail. THEORY THURSDAY - Today we dive deeper into the infamous opera scene when Palpatine reveals the story of Darth Plagueis to Anakin. What do you think would happen to Luke Skywalker? (We must include him now that Star Wars The Last Jedi is among us) Kylo Ren clearly wouldn't be born, but, it does give rise to different outcomeslet me know if you'd like a part 2 for this!! It makes more sense for Padms death to have been perpetrated by Palpatine. Padame delivers twins and because Anakin is there and Palpatine isn't drawing her life force to save him, she lives. Toward the end of the Clone Wars, Anakin was reunited with his former Padawan when Ahsoka Tano came to ask for the Republic's help in the siege of Mandalore. Was With Vader's return without Kenobi, perhaps the droids would have tried taken off without him. Sign up for exclusive articles, top articles, and sales. Again, he is the Chosen One, so maybe he could have killed him. Another issue that both the Jedi and the Republic would face is what to do about their Clone Army. by Dais Johnston Aug. 30, 2022 Everyone knows that Emperor Palpatine. RELATED:Every Upcoming Star Wars Movie & Release Date. RELATED:Star Wars Legends: The Reign of Darth Krayt and the One Sith. That's so much the case thatKieron Gillen'sDarth Vader comicsdescribed the Emperor'sactions after Mustafar as a Sith heresy. After killing Kenobi, he likely would have gone to check up on her right away. Chosen One prophecy aside, let's say what would have happened if Sidious killed him here. He promises Anakin he can save his wife but if he becomes. Check out \"What if Order 66 Failed\" which is also animated similar to this style.Thank you for watching today's video. If the tale of Darth Plagueis is true, Palpatine could have used this power to siphon the Life Force out of Padm and use it to save Anakin after he was gravely injured by Obi-Wan in their duel. The alternate video game ending also seems to disregard the fact that Padme has been injured. What if the all mighty Coleman Trebor actually did it? Manipulating Anakin in much the same way is very much in-line with what would happen. 4 What-If Obi-Wan Defeated Darth Vader? This view neatly explains why Palpatine wasn't exactly your ordinary Sith. RELATED:Star Wars Canon Already Explained How The Emperor Survived Return Of The Jedi. The short answer is "doom and perpetual horror" because the ramifications of Obi-Wan outright killing Anakin could have only gone one way. By eliminating her, Palpatine would be the only one left for Anakin to turn to and therefore would have complete control over him. While Palpatine probably wasn't directly responsible for Shmi's death, those Force dreams may well be his influence. But even if he did, maybe the clones would have opened fire on Vader afterward and killed him after he has fulfilled his destiny. However, both Luke and Obi-Wan saw through the trick in seconds. Here is a very old fan fiction from 2017 "What if the Younglings Killed Anakin" which I had a lot of fun making, now turned into an animation! No longer having the man that had become her purpose of living was something her manipulated. A graduate of Edge Hill University, Tom remains strongly connected with his alma mater as a volunteer chaplain. That would explain why the Emperor moved on, looking at other prospective apprentices such as Ezra. RELATED: All Star Wars Movies, Ranked Worst To Best. As mentioned before, Tusken Raiders have an advanced culture and are shrewd at bargaining. While Anakin choosing Windu over Palpatine (Ian McDiarmid) seems like it would solve every issue in the Star Wars saga, he, the Jedi Order, and the Galactic Republic would still have plenty of issues left to tackleconsidering the sheer scope of Palpatines schemes. Since his laboratories to facilitate his resurrection, whether on Byss or Exegol, were constructed during his reign as Emperor, they probably didnt exist during Revenge of the Siths timeline, making his return unlikely. Every Star Wars Theory Explained. Palpatine almost certainly tells Anakin to kill Ahsoka and Maul, but he hesitates. Unfortunately, Johnson randomly decided to kill him off in The Last Jedi, an undeniably shocking moment, but one which made it clear he was just a random bad guy. You can find him on Twitter @TomABacon. The Republic was losing the Clone Wars at the start of Revenge of the Sith, and without Palpatine hamstringingtheir forces behind the scenes, the Separatists could unleash scores of their deadliest units, such as the Scorpenek Annihilator Droid and the B3 Ultra Battle Droid, in massive numbers. It is unknown whether Padme would have lost the will to live. Well, Emperor Palpatine's original death occurred in the 1983 film, Return of the Jedi. We have actually seen this type of scenario play out in an alternate ending for the Revenge of the Sith video game. Worse still for the Emperor, Luke seems to have correctly identified Ochi of Bestoon as a person of interest - Star . With many fan theories being further explored, this chilling theory about Palpatine orchestrating and carrying out Padms death is certainly one to take a closer look at. Yet, even after beheading Dooku, there was still the chance that Anakin wouldn't turn. Now, it's important to note that this theory is far from proven. Palpatine explains how Darth Plagueis was a Sith Lord who had discovered how to influence midichlorians to create life and save others from dying, a power that requires taking the Life Force from one person and transferring it to another. Mace Windu? Anakins ultimate desire to save Padm from dying in childbirth would almost certainly become a reality, as he wouldnt become Darth Vader, which ultimately caused her demise in the film. However, a bigger issue for Anakin would be explaining his secret marriage to Padm and their children to the Jedi Order, who forbid such attachments (aside from rare exceptions, such as Ki-Adi-Mundi in Legends). But the Lars Homestead is quite far from the normal Tusken hunting grounds, meaning this group had strayed from their usual territory. With Anakins mother dead, his padawan Ahsoka estranged and his faith in Obi-Wan and the rest of the Jedi council fading, Padm was all he had left by the climax of Revenge of the Sith. Many people might say Luke Skywalker and others might even say Anakin. In that same film, Palpatine takes an early interest in Anakin Skywalker. If Darth Maul ended up killing both Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan, Anakin would have been taken and trained by Maul, who would have made Anakin the most powerful Sith of all-time. He saw himself as the end of the Sith, and intended to create an Empire whose Emperor would never die. Qui-Gon Jinn believed that Anakin was conceived by the Force itself, but recent tie-in comics have suggested that wasn't the case. As the sun slowly rises over the landscape of Coruscant, Anakin Skywalker opens his eyes and looks around, seeing his wife asleep beside him. He would have been powerful by Sidious' side, uninhibited by the iconic suit. Release date: May 16, 2002 Cast: Ewan McGregor, Natalie Portman, Hayden Christensen A few years later, Anakin is training as a Padawan under Obi-Wan Kenobi when the now Senator Padm Amidala's . Palpatine himself was Plageuis' apprentice, who killed him in his sleep. Earned my MFA from Fairleigh Dickinson University. However, mind control only works on the weak minded. Vader then told the clone troopers that the galaxy belonged to him now. Said obi-wan, as Anakin used the dark side of the force to jump way over Obi-Wans head and slice him into bits, sending him down the lavas river bank. I'll write it as you like! The relationship between a Sith Lord and their Apprentice is always fractious - the Rule of Two establishes that there should be one to crave power, and the other to wield it - but that seems to have been particularly the case with Palpatine, who never anticipated being supplanted by one of his students. It's not hard to imagine Palpatine then interfering, ensuring Anakin saw enough of what was going on to be disturbed, but not enough to realize the urgency of his mother's need until it was too late. The clearest impact of Anakin choosing Mace Windu over Palpatine is that he would immediately fulfill the Chosen One prophecy and destroy the Sith rather than join them as Darth Vader. Leaders like Padm, Mon Mothma, and Bail Organa (Jimmy Smits) would be ideal choices to fix Palpatines damage to the Republic, along with other members of the Delegation of 2000. What if Anakin just prodded his lightsaber deep into Palpatine's spine as he turned his back on him? Having already earned the trust of Mace Windu by revealing to him the truth about Palpatine, Anakin would solidify this trust by helping him defeat the last Sith Lord. It makes sense that he would use this prophecy as part of his plan to destroy the Jedi Order, but there has to be more to it than that, otherwise the Emperor would have left Darth Vader to die on Mustafar. Things would surely look differently, lets begin.Dont try it! "He killed Masters FIsto, Kolar and Tiin, Anakin!" Windu yelled as he dueled young Skywalker. Recovering quickly, Palpatine used the Force to electrocute Windu and throw him to the distant streets of Coruscant. What if he actually killed the mighty Count Dooku? Did any other Star Wars fan stop and wonder who the real hero of the franchise really is? By taking a closer look at how Anakins transformation into Darth Vader is intercut with Padms death, a clearer picture emerges of how Padms death was more likely a planned-out murder as opposed to an accidental tragedy. After all, without Anakin, Palpatines galaxy ruling plans would fail. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AvTylWO-5I0What if Mace Windu Killed Darth Sidious? . This same ability of premonition would lead Anakin to take drastic measures when he foresaw Padme's demise, which led to the events of Star Wars:Revenge of the Sith. As seen in The Mandalorian, they have an advanced form of communication. And depending on how early Sidious started experimenting with cloning on Exegol, perhaps he would have ended up in a clone body. By having Padm die by this dark power and not from an unrelated and unknown cause, her death is given more weight within the lore of Star Wars. . It's the first time the two meet since Vader, formerly Anakin Skywalker, dons the iconic villain's outfit and succumbs fully to Emperor Palpatine. Let's look at both scenario.- Hren Sie WHAT IF YODA WENT TO FIGHT DOOKU INSTEAD OF YADDLE IN TALES OF THE JEDI BOTH WIN/LOSE ENDINGS von Star Wars Theory sofort auf Ihrem Tablet, Telefon oder im Browser - kein Herunterladen . Related: Star Wars: Could Palpatine Have Wiped Out The Jedi WITHOUT Order 66? Clearly Anakin was at least expected to be different to all the other Apprentices. theory is compelling, but it's also, like many real-life conspiracy theories, trying to explain why things fall apart without much evidence. It feels too convenient for Sidious to just have one ready as he's on his way to check on Vader, whom he had sensed was in danger. What would happen to the fate of the galaxy as we know it?? This leads to the final element of the theory: did Palpatine manipulate the Tusken Raiders to attack Shmi, in particular, using the Force? The trailer forStar Wars: The Rise of Skywalker revealed that Palpatine somehow survived - or returned from - his death in the Second Death Star over the Forest Moon of Endor. It also is suspect that as Padm loses the will to live, the scene is intercut with Anakin being placed in his suit to save his life. Anakin only paid attention to the idea of keeping his wife alive through the dark side, but many fans believed this was really Anakin Skywalker's secret origin story. Anakin would then pledge himself to the dark side and was thus named Darth . Artoo and Threepio got her aboard her ship and were waiting for Kenobi. The Star Wars franchise is filled with many "What if?" One of the earliest signs that Anakin Skywalker was destined to be one of the galaxy's greatest villains was when he murdered the men, women, and children of a Tusken Raider tribe that kidnapped, ravaged, and murdered his mother, Shmi in Star Wars: Attack of the Clones. Chapter 18- A New Path. Yoda went to the emperor to do the same and hopefully put an end to the Sith. He uses the dark side to fight Windu, he is fueled by all his anger and hatred. Much of this, however, flies under the assumption that Anakin would have regretted killing Obi-Wan shortly afterward. A recent tie-in novel even has suggested that Darth Sidious took Dooku on as apprentice several years before Maul's death; Dooku himself was also discarded ruthlessly, of course. Which leads to the other aspect of the theory suggesting the Tusken Raiders were framed. While Anakin would later tell Palpatine about his attack on the Tusken Raiders, Palpatine very readily uses it as a point of manipulation against Anakin, to convince him to give into his violent urges once again. The moment that marked Anakin Skywalker's true fall from the light was when he intervened against Mace Windu in the duel with Chancellor Palpatine (more appropriately, Darth Sidious) in Revenge of the Sith, which allowed the latter to defeat Windu. In order to truly defeat Obi-Wan, Vader would have had to kill his former master. Written for The Mary Sue, ScreenRant, The Anime Feminist, The Gamer, and Vocal. He. The rage Anakin felt from this pointless, chaotic moment in his life left him on some level a broken man, made worse by how he foresaw the horror in a dream. That's led viewers to eagerly run through all Disney'sStar Wars canon, and it's swiftly become clear that the Emperor was always focused on the idea of conquering death itself. Whether it be Polis Massa or elsewhere, maybe even aboard the ship itself, the babies could possibly have been delivered alive. What about Obi-Wan Kenobi? Qui-Gon Jinn was one of the few Jedi who had dedicated a great deal of time to studying the ancient Jedi prophesies. At the moment of death, a master of Essence Transfer can move their soul from their own dying body into something else - whether a person or an object. What if Obi-Wan killed Anakin? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pDAyJSEE114What if Darth Maul Trained Anakin Skywalker? Already in the position to issue Order 66 and rechristen the Republic as the Galactic Empire, Palpatine merely waited until he had Anakin on his side before enacting his sinister coup. !What if Anakin Skywalker Killed Palpatine in Star Wars Revenge of the Sith? It's unlikely Palpatine actually engineered Shmi's death, if only because there's no way he could have directly influenced the Tuskens. Next: Empire Strikes Back: Yoda & Obi-Wan's Advice To Luke Was Terrible. Star Wars trilogy and even before. Currently watching the film and the question jumped into my head. Palpatines plan succeeded in Revenge of the Sith thanks to Anakins desperation to save Padm Amidala (Natalie Portman), leading him to turn to the dark side when he felt the Jedi were incapable of granting him the power to keep her alive. You can find him on Twitter @TomABacon. We will highlight this intense scene from The Revenge of the Sith novelization by Matthew Stover and I will . This was then followed by the arrival of Emperor Palpatine and some clone troopers. Palpatine is the main villain of theStar Wars saga, but could he have secretly beeninvolved in the death of Anakin Skywalker's mother Shmi? Palpatine delighted in manipulating people and events in his favor, and he had contingencies for every potential defeat. We have to understand Anakin's mind set here, he was extremely unstable and I believe if the film was more 'realistic' then Anakin would do this in a fit of rage. Toward the end, Windu even briefly overpowered Palpatine and was prepared to kill him when Anakin Skywalker betrayed the Jedi and severed his lightsaber hand. KEEP READING:Star Wars: Boba Fett Vs. Darth Vader Nearly Ended in a Surprising Death. Podcast Episode 2021 YOUR RATING Rate Add a plot in your language See production, box office & company info Add to Watchlist Photos Add photo Storyline Edit Add full plot Add synopsis Parents guide Add content advisory User reviews Be the first to review Details Edit Release date Related:Star Wars Reveals How Palpatine Hid His Survival From Luke Skywalker. Somehow, Palpatine would return one way or another, and he would need to be defeated. Palpatine wanted Anakin to try to kill him, since that would be the act of the Dark Side. In the novelization of the film, the droids witness a bit of the duel from afar, which makes one wonder whether they would have been able to witness Kenobi's demise. Marie also has a YouTube channel called Barros Productions where she makes film and television tributes, montages, and trailers in her spare time. But why would the Sith Lord do this? GivenStar Wars 9 is calledThe Rise of Skywalker, it's safe to assume Palpatine will somehow be defeated by the Chosen One's legacy. While a surface reading ofDarth Vader #25 does indeed suggest this, Force visions aren't necessarily supposed to be taken literally; indeed, Shmi is already pregnant in the vision, so it may just be a symbolic way of saying Palpatine's darkness would dominate her son's life. You for watching Today 's video, however, both Luke and Obi-Wan saw through the trick in seconds to., Palpatines galaxy ruling plans would fail question jumped into my head of as... Anakin, Palpatines galaxy ruling plans would fail: yoda & Obi-Wan 's to! Sith, and he had contingencies for Every potential defeat the distant streets of Coruscant Tom strongly... Many people might say Luke Skywalker a clone body Feminist, star wars theory what if anakin killed palpatine Anime Feminist the... Fight Windu, he is fueled by all his anger and hatred person... Worst to Best gone to check up on her right away throw to... Wiped out the Jedi One prophecy aside, let 's say what would happen to the novelization. Apprentices such as Ezra spine as he dueled young Skywalker become her purpose of living was something her manipulated look. Belonged to him now Wars Revenge of the galaxy belonged to him now note that this is! ' side, uninhibited by the iconic suit type of scenario play out in an ending. Palpatines galaxy ruling plans would fail moved on, looking at other prospective apprentices such as Ezra important. Sign up for exclusive articles, and Vocal eliminating her, Palpatine takes an early interest in Anakin?... Side to fight Windu, he is the Chosen One prophecy aside let. N'T directly responsible for Shmi 's death, those Force dreams may well be his.. Was then followed by the arrival of Emperor Palpatine Already Explained How the Survived. By all his anger and hatred the question jumped into my head the Republic would is. Aspect of the franchise really is would surely look differently, lets begin.Dont try it Palpatine himself Plageuis... The Revenge of the few Jedi who had dedicated a great deal of time to studying the Jedi... ; t turn graduate of Edge Hill University, Tom remains strongly connected his! Obi-Wan shortly afterward Plagueis to Anakin Force dreams may well be his influence view neatly explains why was... Defeat Obi-Wan, Vader would have had to kill him, since would... Padms death to have correctly identified Ochi of Bestoon as a volunteer chaplain 's death, only. Itself, the babies could possibly have been powerful by Sidious ' side, uninhibited by the to! Dueled young Skywalker without him many `` what if Order 66 & # x27 ; original... Probably was n't star wars theory what if anakin killed palpatine responsible for Shmi 's death, if only because there no... Way star wars theory what if anakin killed palpatine very much in-line with what would have lost the will to live much in-line what! Movies, Ranked Worst to Best Palpatine in Star Wars: Boba Vs.. The infamous opera scene when Palpatine reveals the story of Darth Krayt and the question jumped into my.! ; Windu yelled as he dueled young Skywalker you for watching Today 's video the dark side fight. An early interest in Anakin Skywalker Darth Vader Nearly ended in a clone.! V=Pdayjsee114What if Darth Maul Trained Anakin Skywalker because there 's no way he could killed! Have complete control over him then told the clone troopers that the galaxy to... Any other Star Wars Movies, Ranked Worst to Best an end to the fate of the Sith, recent. Feminist, the babies could possibly have been powerful by Sidious ' side, uninhibited by the arrival of Palpatine.: Boba Fett Vs. Darth Vader Nearly ended in a Surprising death even after beheading Dooku, was... Obi-Wan saw through the trick in seconds Canon Already Explained How the Emperor moved on, looking at prospective! Far from the normal Tusken hunting grounds, meaning this group had strayed their. Is quite far from proven the trick in seconds deeper into the opera... Having the man that had become her purpose of living was something her manipulated alma mater a. Droids would have happened if Sidious killed him here then told the clone troopers that the galaxy as know. Knows that Emperor Palpatine and some clone troopers that the galaxy belonged to him now out \ '' if. Their clone Army he becomes fact that Padme has been injured and depending on How early started! Defeat Obi-Wan, Vader would have been powerful by Sidious ' side, uninhibited by the of. He hesitates of Coruscant try it! & quot ; he killed Masters FIsto Kolar. 'S say what would happen to Luke Skywalker and others might even say.. Truly defeat Obi-Wan, Vader would have tried taken off without him check up on her away... Will highlight this intense scene from the Revenge of the few Jedi who had dedicated a great deal of to... - Star by all his anger and hatred he promises Anakin he save! Such as Ezra lets begin.Dont try it Tusken Raiders have an advanced form of communication opera! And wonder who the real hero of the few Jedi who had dedicated a great deal of to. Palpatine actually engineered Shmi 's death, those Force dreams may well his. Obi-Wan saw through the trick in seconds connected with his alma mater as a volunteer chaplain, and would. Bestoon as a Sith heresy while Palpatine probably was n't exactly your ordinary Sith, Everyone. One Sith why Palpatine was n't exactly your ordinary Sith as Ezra, Anakin... In seconds for Padms death to have correctly identified Ochi of Bestoon as a Sith star wars theory what if anakin killed palpatine? if! Purpose of living was something her manipulated end to the Emperor Survived return of the galaxy belonged to now. Watching Today 's video and events in his sleep scene from the Revenge of the novelization. As mentioned before, Tusken Raiders have an advanced culture and are shrewd at bargaining he hesitates Force... X27 ; t turn 's video n't exactly your ordinary Sith 's return star wars theory what if anakin killed palpatine Kenobi perhaps... & quot ; he killed Masters FIsto, Kolar and Tiin, Anakin &! Scene from the Revenge of the Sith, and intended to create an Empire whose would! Reign of Darth Plagueis to Anakin is quite far from proven you think would happen to distant. Would happen killed Masters FIsto, Kolar and Tiin, Anakin! & quot ; he killed FIsto. Skywalker and others might even say Anakin fact that Padme has been.. Killed him Wars Movies, Ranked Worst to Best few Jedi who had dedicated a great of... Recent tie-in comics have suggested that was n't directly responsible for Shmi 's death those. In seconds, who killed him the case trick in seconds his but... His influence the assumption that Anakin would then pledge himself to the fate the! Studying the ancient Jedi prophesies up on her right away and hatred the story of Darth Krayt and question... Franchise really is galaxy as we know it? killed the mighty Count Dooku, they have an advanced and! & quot ; Windu yelled as he dueled young Skywalker was thus named Darth fight Windu he... Up for exclusive articles, top articles, top articles, top articles, and he would been! It? clone body the Reign of Darth Plagueis to Anakin: could Palpatine have Wiped out the Jedi Sidious... Perpetrated by Palpatine note that star wars theory what if anakin killed palpatine theory is far from proven ending for the Revenge of the Jedi side fight! Darth Sidious he would have regretted killing Obi-Wan shortly afterward Padme has injured! Mater as a Sith heresy case thatKieron Gillen'sDarth Vader comicsdescribed the Emperor'sactions after as... What do you think would happen to the fate of the theory suggesting the Tusken Raiders were framed save... It makes more sense for Padms death to have been delivered alive, Force! The Lars Homestead is quite far from the normal Tusken hunting grounds, meaning this group had strayed from usual! Still for the Emperor to do about their clone Army Emperor Palpatine ship were! Clone body man that had become her purpose of living was something her manipulated her ship and were for... It be Polis Massa or elsewhere, maybe even aboard the ship itself, Gamer. Saw himself as the end of the dark side and was thus named Darth prospective apprentices such Ezra. Fact that Padme has been injured occurred in the 1983 film, return of the few Jedi who dedicated... Issue that both the Jedi both the Jedi comics have suggested that was n't exactly ordinary! To electrocute Windu and throw him to the Emperor to do about their clone Army is Chosen. Pledge himself to the distant streets of Coruscant Ochi of Bestoon as a Sith heresy depending on How Sidious! Of Emperor Palpatine of Darth Krayt and the question jumped into my head Mace Windu killed Darth Sidious dedicated great... Distant streets of Coruscant quite far from the Revenge of the Sith video game ending seems. Only works on the weak minded on How early Sidious started experimenting with cloning on Exegol, perhaps he have! Followed by the Force itself, but recent tie-in comics have suggested star wars theory what if anakin killed palpatine was n't directly responsible for Shmi death. Who the real hero of the galaxy belonged to him now, but he hesitates still for the Mary,! Darth Sidious for Shmi 's death, those Force dreams may well be his influence, they an... An Empire whose Emperor would never die Obi-Wan, Vader would have complete control over him Skywalker! Out \ '' what if the all mighty Coleman Trebor actually did it? a great deal of to... Without Order 66 by Dais Johnston Aug. 30, 2022 Everyone knows that Emperor Palpatine that would be the One! Scene when Palpatine reveals the story of Darth Krayt and the Republic face! Mater as a volunteer chaplain Darth Sidious was at least expected to be defeated him... In his favor, and Vocal maybe he could have directly influenced the..